Skip to content
© Copyright, Criminal Cases Review Commission 2026.

Aujla, Narinder

Published:

Narinder Aujla, 61, was the sub-postmaster at the Caledonia Post Office branch in Dudley between June 1991 and April 1998. He was convicted of theft and spent four months in prison after he was unable to account for £10,000 of losses after the system was installed. 

About a year after the Capture software was installed, Mr Aujla began seeing discrepancies on the balance sheets. He could not find any errors which would have accounted for the losses he was seeing. 

When the losses were small, Mr Aujla had been balancing the books by adding his own money. This became impossible when the losses were higher. The Post Office helpline advised Mr Aujla to ‘roll the losses over’ to the next week, but each time he did this, the total loss increased.  

In the Autumn of 1996, Mr Aujla’s branch was audited, and he was told there was a £10,000 loss. He was interviewed about the loss and said he did not know what had caused it.  

Mr Aujla was prosecuted and convicted of five counts of theft after a trial at Wolverhampton Crown Court in March 1998. He was sentenced to four months’ imprisonment. After his release, the Post Office pursued Mr Aujla for the losses and he subsequently paid back £10,000 in instalments.  

Mr Aujla never exercised his right of appeal against conviction. 

Following concerns raised about Capture during the Post Office Horizon IT Inquiry, the Government engaged Kroll Associates UK Ltd to conduct an independent investigation into Capture, which found a reasonable likelihood that it could create accounting shortfalls for sub-postmasters. 

A report by the computing consultancy MFC Partnership, commissioned on behalf of sub-postmaster Patrica Owen by her solicitors in 1997, identified several faults with the software that would not be necessarily apparent to users. In October 2025, the CCRC referred Mrs Owen’s theft convictions to the Court of Appeal on the grounds her prosecution was an abuse of process. 

Upon becoming aware of concerns regarding the reliability of Capture, Mr Aujla applied to the CCRC in June 2025. Following a review, the CCRC found that, in light of the Kroll and MFC reports, together with new evidence contained in Mr Aujla’s witness statement, there was a real possibility the Court of Appeal would conclude that it was an abuse of process to prosecute Mr Aujla and would quash his conviction. 

The CCRC referred the conviction in November 2026.